"A waxy texture sets the stage for the graphite, honey and whole-grain bread notes. It shows some intensity, a fine mousse and open structure for aging. Good length. Drink now. 89 points" Wine Spectator

"A touch cheesy in aroma, this settles into apple, peach and hazelnut flavors. On the sharp side, with a grainy texture that emerges on the finish. A powerful, dry Champagne, with a biscuitlike aftertaste. Needs food. Drink now through 2020. 93 points" Wine Spectator

"There's plenty of finesse in this sleek Champagne, along with an airy texture and loads of grip. Graphite, lemon, toast and mineral aromas and flavors prevail, and this takes on a chalky edge on the lingering aftertaste. Best from 2010 through 2028. 92 points" Wine Spectator

"A vibrant, berry-inflected rosé. Light and delicate, this is balanced and firms up on the chalky finish. Drink now. 88 points" Wine Spectator